As part of broader proposed changes to the DH conference, we are seeking feedback on a proposal for a new form for DH conference reviews in ConfTool. The evaluation criteria for submissions are a key factor in shaping the reviewing process and, ultimately, the conference programme. We have developed a proposal for a new set of evaluation criteria and the corresponding review questions, as well as for a new way of designing the ConfTool review form. Key changes include more closely connecting the decision on numerical scores and textual comments, for each review question, and a new evaluation criterion that takes a submission’s contribution to the diversity of the programme into account. Please submit your feedback via online survey by July 31, 2023. We thank you in advance for your input. We aim to have new criteria and questions in place for DH2024.